Using Omega-3 Fish Oils
Pretty much everyone (including your family doctor and cardiologist) now know
the benefits of fish oil supplementation. I wanted to give you a quick review
and some recommendations about the issue of EPA/DHA supplementation.
The strongest data supportive of benefits from fish oil is in the area of
cardiovascular disease. The omega-3’s are unique to marine life and are
synthesized from ocean micro-organisms, and then make their way up the food
chain to people. The recommended dose for heart protection is 1000mg. Many
capsules available over-the-counter vary in dosage so read the labels and
don’t assume all fish oil is the same.
Although you can obtain your 1000mg of EPA/DHA by eating a 3 ounce serving of
salmon or sardines, or 4 ounces of tuna, I would not recommend that you do so.
If you do, you will also be getting something you do NOT want to eat every day,
the toxic metal MERCURY. Large body fish and most fish oil capsules do contain
mercury, and salmon and tuna are among the most contaminated fish. Fish oil
helps normalize blood fats, and in higher doses (2 to 4 grams per day) is an
especially effective therapy for elevated
triglycerides.
Supposedly the Consumer’s Union studied fish oil caps for accuracy in labeling
and contents of contaminants, and did not find a significant problem with
mercury. If they are going by the EPA’s published standards, those conclusions
may not be trustworthy. They do make the interesting point that the more toxic
form of mercury is methyl mercury which is water, but not oil soluble. This
means that theoretically it should not be found at all in the oil capsules, but
should remain behind in the fish meal itself. I will give you more feedback
about this issue after I research other resources for capsule toxicity and
contamination data.
The main concern with higher dose fish oil therapy is the risk of it thinning
the blood too much, thus causing abnormal bleeding. Fortunately, a recent study
of bypass and angioplasty patients proved that doses up to 7000mg of EPA/DHA,
even when combined with aspirin or coumadin, did NOT increase the risk of
bleeding. The major complaint about fish oil therapy is burping up a fishy
after-taste. The purer more refined products will cause this less often, and
with the others, you can lessen this problem by taking the oil with food or
digestive enzymes, and perhaps try keeping the caps in the freezer. The common
vegetarian alternative to fish oil is flax seed oil. This is a vegetable oil
that is rich in alpha linoleic acid (ALA), which is a shorter chain omega-3 oil.
The problem is that although ALA is essential, it does not easily convert to
EPA/DHA in the body, has not been shown to lower triglycerides, an evidence for
a protective role in heart disease is weaker than with fish oil. Thus I must
conclude, and so advise my patients, that ALA in flax is NOT an effective
substitute for EPA and DHA. There are some researchers who are now saying that
the pendulum is swinging to the opposite side of the extreme. It has always been
felt that Americans eat far more omega-6 fats than omega-3 fats. These
researchers say tests of many individuals (who now are often on fish oil
supplementation) can reveal abnormally high levels of EPA. The ideal ratio of
omega 6 to 3 fats has not been fully worked out. Statistic do suggest that red
blood cell levels of EPA and DHA (which can be measured in the office) greater
than 8% are protective, while levels less than 4% place patients at increased
risk.